On a chilly Tuesday morning in early November, Redmond-bred screenwriter and actress Geena Pietromonaco pointed out something she felt was missing from the Pacific Northwest filmmaking landscape. Though there’s been a recent hike in narrative features made in the region, she observed, much of what’s come out can be filed under two categories: scary things or sad things. “Those are all great, and I’m happy to act in them,” said the grey turtleneck-clad Pietromonaco, who spoke over Zoom from her Greenwood home. “But I’m like, ‘I love comedy.’ That is my sweet spot; that’s my bread and butter. I want to write a fun comedy.”

Pietromonaco’s latest project both makes good on that impulse and could very well provide Northwest residents with a new seasonal classic to rewatch every holiday season. Shot in Seattle and co-starring “Friday Night Lights” fan favorite Zach Gilford, “Christmas Pop-Up” could in some respects be compared to a Hallmark movie. Case in point with its enviable real estate (e.g., a spacious, $2,600-a-month apartment directly in front of Pike Place Market) and cozily formulaic storytelling, which roots for a romance between Will, a grouchy celebrity chef with a heart of gold (Gilford), and Fran (Pietromonaco), a harried, cash-strapped designer who simultaneously must visually spruce up a career-revitalizing event for Will and move out of her and her ex-boyfriend’s apartment before New Year’s. 

But the Hallmark comparison also does a disservice to Pietromonaco’s witty writing; her fairly frank portrayal of recognizable-to-Seattleites financial anxiety; and her own charming lead performance, whose self-deprecation and spells of goofiness has hints of Sandra Bullock or Ginger Rogers but otherwise announces her in a league of her own. There was never a moment, Pietromonaco said, where she considered anybody but herself playing Fran. “I’m an actor first, writer second,” said Pietromonaco, whose jokey and expressive way of speaking trickles into her performance. “I was like, ‘What’s a way to show my stuff?’”

The idea for “Christmas Pop-Up” arrived around November 2024, when Pietromonaco was coming off a busy season and “naturally felt the need to fill it back up immediately.” She’d started, then abandoned, several feature-length scripts in the past. She figured her newfound freedom could help force her to complete a draft. Then, one day, she was driving through her neighborhood and noticed, on the corner of 85th and Greenwood, a restaurant space with butcher paper covering its windows, its identity unclear. Pietromonaco’s mind started filling in the blanks. “I was like, ‘Oh, what if that was a little Christmas restaurant — a little fine-dining thing?’” she recounted. “And I knew I had wanted to write a Christmas movie because I love them — I think they’re fun and they’re nice and they’re formulaic — and so it felt like, ‘Let’s just try that.’” 

Molly Muse directing Geena Pietromonaco. Photo by John Eckenrode

Pietromonaco ended up getting her first draft done in less than a week. “I was too embarrassed to talk to anyone about it because I thought it was too cute and too sweet and silly,” she said. “So it took some encouraging from other people to actually carry on with it.” 

“Christmas Pop-Up”’s director, Phinney Ridge-based Molly Muse, had gotten to know Pietromonaco through the Seattle Film Society. The pair both had shorts screen during one of the organization’s events; they also later together worked on a feature, the Walla Walla-shot “Devil’s Wine,” that Pietromonaco acted in and Muse first assistant directed. While catching up over coffee later on, they talked about wanting to collaborate again. Pietromonaco mentioned having an idea for a Christmas movie; when they subsequently had a meet-up, the film was written. “I immediately asked if I could direct it,” said Muse, who though not the biggest Christmas-movie fan — she praised 1990’s “Home Alone,” for example, but said Hallmark movies give her “the willies” — loves the season’s warmth and loves romantic comedies.

She also wanted to support Pietromonaco. “I just really respect and admire Geena’s ability to write a showcase for her own talents,” said Muse, who spoke alongside Pietromonaco over Zoom. “I think it’s harder than it seems like it’s gonna be.”

Although it was immediately settled who would play Fran — a decision, Pietromonaco and Muse noted, that received some pushback from industry leaders who’d have preferred putting their money behind a movie with a “name actor” — finding “Christmas Pop-Up”’s romantic lead was a trickier process. Pietromonaco and Muse had a wishlist of pie-in-the-sky picks including Chris Hemsworth and Michael B. Jordan before executive producer June Peters hooked them up with a casting consultant in LA. “They looked at our list and they’re like, no,” Muse said. “But they gave us back a new list and they’re like, ‘Here’s, like, 50 dudes who could play this role,’ and so we watched a bunch of tapes and turned that list into 20.” 

That was then whittled down to three people. When Gilford, whom Muse and Pietromonaco were fans of through his work on “Friday Night Lights” and with contemporary horror heavyweight Mike Flanagan, read the script, he loved it and signed on. He wasn’t able to come to the rehearsal the day before production commenced, though, so the shoot was the first time Pietromonaco and Muse ever heard him say his lines. “Thank goodness he was good,” Pietromonaco said with a laugh.

Zach Gilford and Geena Pietromonaco in ‘Christmas Pop-Up.’ Photo by Ryan Purcell

Its shoot assisted by a production incentive from Washington Film Works — which, essentially, helps area filmmakers with the precarious investment process — “Christmas Pop-Up” was shot across 17 days in January in Seattle, mostly downtown. The decision was a double-edged sword. The area was, blessedly, mostly barren post-holidays and still had seasonal decorations up. Many crew members were readily available because commercial work is typically slower at the start of a new year. But the tight schedule and budget also sometimes resulted in 16-hour days. Seahawks mania had to be worked around; wonky holiday-abiding SAG-office hours pushed deadlines up. But ultimately, spirits largely remained high, and “we really came out of this with a tight-knit group and family; we all love each other so much,” Muse said. “Everyone is so proud of this film, and it really just feels very warm and fulfilling.” 

“It’s just such a testament to how hardworking and amazing the talent is here,” added Pietromonaco.

“Christmas Pop-Up” has been well-received during screenings at the Austin Film Festival, where the movie won the Comedy Vanguard Audience Award, and Seattle’s Egyptian Theater. It has more planned at the Edmonds Theater (Nov. 23 and 30), Bremerton’s Roxy Theater (Dec. 6), and the SIFF Cinema Uptown (Dec. 19) in addition to an on-demand release on Amazon Prime beginning Nov. 27. (Streaming on-demand will start on Dec. 4 on Apple TV+, Fandango, and YouTube.) It was important to Muse and Pietromonaco to have the movie seen in theaters for a reasonable period rather than have it be available to watch online right away. “We just want to get it out and in front of as many people as possible to do right by everybody who put their heart and soul into the movie,” Muse said.

“To be able to be in a room with people experiencing it is such a gift,” Pietromonaco added. “The other day, we had our premiere in Portland, and spoiler alert, (Will and Fran) kiss at one point in the movie, and someone in the audience goes, ‘Finally!’ Like screams it. And I’m like, ‘That’s what we’ve been missing, right?’ (With) COVID, no one was going to theaters, and now people are back. We love enjoying things together, and the fact that we get to contribute to that in any way, it’s bliss. It’s the best of the best.” 

Among Pietromonaco’s personal goals for “Christmas Pop-Up” was to make people feel good. A self-described anxious person, she knows how much of a difference it can make to watch something that temporarily alleviates one’s worries. “Everything is so scary all the time, and everything’s loud and mad, and everyone’s mad and scared,” she said. “I just want to give people a chance to feel good, escape a little — have a little levity.”